Financial Bulletin Situation 4, 2022

Excessive inflation is a serious problem for everybody. The Governing Council will be sure that inflation returns to its 2% goal over the medium time period.

In Could inflation once more rose considerably, primarily due to surging power and meals costs, together with because of the impression of the conflict in Ukraine. However inflation pressures have broadened and intensified, with costs for a lot of items and companies growing strongly. Eurosystem employees have revised their baseline inflation projections up considerably. These projections point out that inflation will stay undesirably elevated for a while. Nevertheless, moderating power prices, the easing of provide disruptions associated to the pandemic and the normalisation of financial coverage are anticipated to result in a decline in inflation. The June 2022 Eurosystem employees macroeconomic projections for the euro space foresee annual inflation at 6.8% in 2022, earlier than it’s projected to say no to three.5% in 2023 and a couple of.1% in 2024 – larger than within the March projections. Which means that headline inflation on the finish of the projection horizon is projected to be barely above the ECB’s goal. Inflation excluding power and meals is projected to common 3.3% in 2022, 2.8% in 2023 and a couple of.3% in 2024 – additionally above the March projections.

Russia’s unjustified aggression in direction of Ukraine continues to weigh on the economic system in Europe and past. It’s disrupting commerce, resulting in shortages of supplies and contributing to excessive power and commodity costs. These components will proceed to weigh on confidence and dampen development, particularly within the close to time period. Nevertheless, the situations are in place for the economic system to proceed to develop on account of the continuing reopening of the economic system, a powerful labour market, fiscal assist and financial savings constructed up through the pandemic. As soon as present headwinds abate, financial exercise is predicted to select up once more. This outlook is broadly mirrored within the Eurosystem employees macroeconomic projections, which foresee annual actual GDP development at 2.8% in 2022, 2.1% in 2023 and a couple of.1% in 2024. In contrast with the March projections, the outlook has been revised down considerably for 2022 and 2023, whereas for 2024 it has been revised up.

On the premise of the up to date evaluation, the Governing Council determined to take additional steps in normalising its financial coverage. All through this course of, the Governing Council will preserve optionality, data-dependence, gradualism and adaptability within the conduct of financial coverage.

First, the Governing Council determined to finish web asset purchases underneath its asset buy programme (APP) as of 1 July 2022. The Governing Council intends to proceed reinvesting, in full, the principal funds from maturing securities bought underneath the APP for an prolonged time frame previous the date when it begins elevating the important thing ECB rates of interest and, in any case, for so long as essential to keep up ample liquidity situations and an acceptable financial coverage stance.

Second, the Governing Council undertook a cautious overview of the situations which, based on its ahead steering, ought to be happy earlier than it begins elevating the important thing ECB rates of interest. Because of this evaluation, the Governing Council concluded that these situations have been happy. Accordingly, and consistent with its coverage sequencing, the Governing Council intends to boost the important thing ECB rates of interest by 25 foundation factors at its July financial coverage assembly. Wanting additional forward, it expects to boost the important thing ECB rates of interest once more in September. The calibration of this charge enhance will rely on the up to date medium-term inflation outlook. If the medium-term inflation outlook persists or deteriorates, a bigger increment might be acceptable on the September assembly.

Third, past September, based mostly on its present evaluation, the Governing Council anticipates {that a} gradual however sustained path of additional will increase in rates of interest might be acceptable. According to the dedication to its 2% medium-term goal, the tempo at which the Governing Council adjusts its financial coverage will rely on the incoming knowledge and the way it assesses inflation will develop within the medium time period.

Throughout the Governing Council’s mandate, underneath pressured situations, flexibility will stay a component of financial coverage every time threats to financial coverage transmission jeopardise the attainment of worth stability.

The financial fallout from the Russian invasion of Ukraine and the brand new lockdowns in China symbolize two key headwinds to international development within the close to time period. Survey indicators affirm that international exercise is moderating. Disrupted financial exercise in Asia and the conflict in Ukraine are placing strain on international provide chains, following a short interval of easing earlier this yr. Provide chain and commodity market disruptions are stoking inflation amid rising proof that inflationary pressures are intensifying and broadening. Growing inflationary pressures are additionally evident from the rising export costs of the euro space’s opponents. Commodity costs stay risky and topic to produce dangers, whereas monetary situations have tightened. World monetary situations tightened, reflecting financial coverage normalisation, falling costs of dangerous belongings and rising yields. Towards this background, the June 2022 Eurosystem employees macroeconomic projections point out that international actual GDP – excluding the euro space – will develop at 3.0% in 2022, 3.4% in 2023 and three.6% in 2024 – a weaker development trajectory than foreseen within the March projections. The 2 key headwinds are projected to weigh considerably on commerce within the close to time period, however their impression is predicted to dissipate thereafter. The projected development in euro space international demand is extra subdued and has undergone extra important downward revisions than development in world imports, as European international locations exterior the euro space with tighter financial hyperlinks to Russia and Ukraine are extra affected by the financial shocks triggered by the invasion. In an setting of elevated uncertainty, the steadiness of dangers across the baseline projections is firmly tilted to the draw back for development and to the upside for inflation.

The Russia-Ukraine conflict is severely affecting the euro space economic system and the outlook remains to be surrounded by excessive uncertainty. However the situations are in place for the economic system to proceed to develop and to get better additional over the medium time period. Within the close to time period, the Governing Council expects exercise to be dampened by excessive power prices, the deterioration within the phrases of commerce, larger uncertainty and the antagonistic impression of excessive inflation on disposable revenue. The conflict in Ukraine and renewed pandemic restrictions in China have made provide bottlenecks worse once more. Because of this, corporations face larger prices and disruptions of their provide chains, and the outlook for his or her future output has deteriorated.

Regardless of a greater than anticipated final result in 2021, the outlook for the euro space finances steadiness has deteriorated considerably for the reason that finalisation of the March 2022 ECB employees macroeconomic projections. The extra antagonistic outlook is expounded to a worsening of the financial cycle, elevated anticipated curiosity funds and extra discretionary authorities spending. Fiscal assist measures have been aimed specifically at countering the rising value of dwelling for shoppers, but in addition at financing defence capacities and supporting refugees from the conflict in Ukraine. Nonetheless, based on the June 2022 Eurosystem employees macroeconomic projections, the euro space authorities finances deficit is predicted to proceed falling – from 5.1% of GDP in 2021 to three.8% in 2022 and additional to 2.4% by the tip of the forecast horizon. After the sturdy loosening through the coronavirus disaster in 2020, the fiscal stance tightened final yr and is projected to proceed to tighten steadily in 2022 and 2023. The projected slight tightening in 2022 is especially because of the reversal of a big a part of the pandemic emergency assist, which might be solely partially compensated by further stimulus measures in response to the power worth shock and different spending associated to the Russia-Ukraine conflict. The fiscal tightening is projected to be considerably stronger in 2023, when most of the latest assist measures compensating for the impression of excessive power costs are projected to run out. In 2024 a extra impartial stance is predicted, though, in comparison with the pre-pandemic interval, important fiscal assist to the economic system is projected to stay in place.

Inflation rose additional to eight.1% in Could. Though governments have intervened and have helped gradual power inflation, power costs stand 39.2% above their ranges one yr in the past. Market-based indicators recommend that international power costs will keep excessive within the close to time period however will then reasonable to some extent. Meals costs rose 7.5% in Could, partly reflecting the significance of Ukraine and Russia among the many predominant international producers of agricultural items. Costs have additionally gone up extra strongly due to renewed provide bottlenecks and due to recovering home demand, particularly within the companies sector, because the euro space economic system reopens. Value rises have gotten extra widespread throughout sectors. Accordingly, measures of underlying inflation have been rising additional. The labour market continues to enhance, with unemployment remaining at its historic low of 6.8% in April. Job vacancies throughout many sectors present that there’s sturdy demand for labour. Wage development, together with in forward-looking indicators, has began to select up. Over time, the strengthening of the economic system and a few catch-up results ought to assist sooner development in wages. Whereas most measures of longer-term inflation expectations derived from monetary markets and from professional surveys stand at round 2%, preliminary indicators of above-target revisions in these measures warrant shut monitoring.

Following the surge in inflation in early 2022, the outlook is for larger and extra persistent inflation. Headline HICP inflation is predicted to stay very excessive for many of 2022, averaging 6.8%, earlier than abating steadily from 2023 and converging to the ECB’s inflation goal within the second half of 2024. Value pressures will stay exceptionally excessive within the close to time period owing to elevated oil and fuel costs and will increase in meals commodity costs, which have been strongly affected by the conflict in Ukraine, in addition to the consequences of the reopening of the economic system and international provide shortages. The anticipated decline in inflation to three.5% in 2023 and a couple of.1% in 2024 primarily displays an assumed moderation in power and meals commodity costs within the absence of further shocks, as embedded in futures costs. As well as, the continuing normalisation of financial coverage, to the extent that it’s mirrored in larger rate of interest assumptions (consistent with market expectations), will contribute to the moderation in inflation, with the same old transmission lags. HICP inflation excluding power and meals will stay very elevated till the tip of 2022, however thereafter it’s anticipated to say no because the upward pressures from the reopening of the economic system subside and as provide bottlenecks and power enter value pressures ease. The continued financial restoration, tightening labour markets and a few results from compensation for larger inflation on wages – that are anticipated to develop at charges properly above historic averages – indicate elevated underlying inflation till the tip of the projection horizon, though the baseline assumes that longer-term inflation expectations will stay properly anchored. In contrast with the March 2022 ECB employees projections, inflation has been revised up considerably. This displays latest knowledge surprises, larger power and meals commodity costs, extra persistent upward pressures from provide disruptions, stronger wage development and the depreciation of the euro change charge. These results greater than offset the downward impression of the rise within the rate of interest assumptions and the weaker development outlook.

The Governing Council judges that the dangers regarding the pandemic have declined, however the conflict in Ukraine continues to be a big draw back threat to development. Particularly, a serious threat could be an extra disruption within the power provide to the euro space, as mirrored within the draw back state of affairs included within the employees projections. Moreover, if the conflict have been to escalate, financial sentiment may worsen, supply-side constraints may enhance, and power and meals prices may stay persistently larger than anticipated. The dangers surrounding inflation are totally on the upside. The dangers to the medium-term inflation outlook embody a sturdy worsening of the manufacturing capability of the euro space economic system, persistently excessive power and meals costs, inflation expectations rising above the ECB’s goal and better than anticipated wage rises. Nevertheless, if demand have been to weaken over the medium time period, it will decrease pressures on costs.

Based mostly on its up to date evaluation, the Governing Council determined to finish web asset purchases underneath the APP as of 1 July 2022. The Governing Council intends to proceed reinvesting, in full, the principal funds from maturing securities bought underneath the APP for an prolonged time frame previous the date when it begins elevating the important thing ECB rates of interest and, in any case, for so long as essential to keep up ample liquidity situations and an acceptable financial coverage stance.

As regards the pandemic emergency buy programme (PEPP), the Governing Council intends to reinvest the principal funds from maturing securities bought underneath the programme till not less than the tip of 2024. In any case, the long run roll-off of the PEPP portfolio might be managed to keep away from interference with the suitable financial coverage stance.

Within the occasion of renewed market fragmentation associated to the pandemic, PEPP reinvestments could be adjusted flexibly throughout time, asset lessons and jurisdictions at any time. This might embody buying bonds issued by the Hellenic Republic over and above rollovers of redemptions with the intention to keep away from an interruption of purchases in that jurisdiction, which may impair the transmission of financial coverage to the Greek economic system whereas it’s nonetheless recovering from the fallout from the pandemic. Internet purchases underneath the PEPP may be resumed, if essential, to counter adverse shocks associated to the pandemic.

The Governing Council undertook a cautious overview of the situations which, based on its ahead steering, ought to be happy earlier than it begins elevating the important thing ECB rates of interest. Because of this evaluation, the Governing Council concluded that these situations have been happy.

Accordingly, and consistent with its coverage sequencing, the Governing Council intends to boost the important thing ECB rates of interest by 25 foundation factors at its July financial coverage assembly. Within the meantime, the Governing Council determined to depart the rate of interest on the primary refinancing operations and the rates of interest on the marginal lending facility and the deposit facility unchanged at 0.00%, 0.25% and -0.50% respectively.

Wanting additional forward, the Governing Council expects to boost the important thing ECB rates of interest once more in September. The calibration of this charge enhance will rely on the up to date medium-term inflation outlook. If the medium-term inflation outlook persists or deteriorates, a bigger increment might be acceptable on the September assembly.

Past September, based mostly on its present evaluation, the Governing Council anticipates {that a} gradual however sustained path of additional will increase in rates of interest might be acceptable. According to the Governing Council’s dedication to its 2% medium-term goal, the tempo at which the Governing Council adjusts its financial coverage will rely on the incoming knowledge and the way it assesses inflation will develop within the medium time period.

The Governing Council will proceed to observe financial institution funding situations and be certain that the maturing of operations underneath the third collection of focused longer-term refinancing operations (TLTRO III) doesn’t hamper the sleek transmission of its financial coverage. The Governing Council may even repeatedly assess how focused lending operations are contributing to its financial coverage stance. As introduced beforehand, the particular situations relevant underneath TLTRO III will finish on 23 June 2022.

The Governing Council stands prepared to regulate all of its devices, incorporating flexibility if warranted, to make sure that inflation stabilises at its 2% goal over the medium time period. The pandemic has proven that, underneath pressured situations, flexibility within the design and conduct of asset purchases has helped to counter the impaired transmission of financial coverage and made the Governing Council’s efforts to realize its aim simpler. Throughout the ECB’s mandate, underneath pressured situations, flexibility will stay a component of financial coverage every time threats to financial coverage transmission jeopardise the attainment of worth stability.

Following an advert hoc assembly on 15 June the Governing Council additional communicated that it’s going to apply flexibility in reinvesting redemptions coming due within the PEPP portfolio, with a view to preserving the functioning of the financial coverage transmission mechanism, a precondition for the ECB to have the ability to ship on its worth stability mandate. As well as, the Governing Council determined to mandate the related Eurosystem Committees along with the ECB companies to speed up the completion of the design of a brand new anti-fragmentation instrument for consideration by the Governing Council.

The financial fallout from the Russian invasion of Ukraine and the brand new lockdowns in China symbolize headwinds to international development within the close to time period. Towards this background, the June 2022 Eurosystem employees macroeconomic projections anticipate that international actual GDP – excluding the euro space – will develop at 3.0% in 2022, 3.4% in 2023 and three.6% in 2024, a weaker development trajectory in contrast with the March projections. The implications of the Russian invasion and the pandemic measures in China are projected to weigh considerably on commerce within the close to time period, however their impression is predicted to dissipate thereafter. The projected development of euro space international demand is extra subdued and has undergone extra important downward revisions in contrast with world imports, reflecting a worse outlook for Russia and for European international locations exterior the euro space with tighter financial hyperlinks to Russia and Ukraine. In an setting of elevated uncertainty, the steadiness of dangers across the baseline projections is firmly tilted to the draw back for development and to the upside for inflation.

The financial fallout from the conflict and the brand new lockdowns in China symbolize headwinds to international development within the close to time period. By way of commodity costs, provide chains and uncertainty, the implications of the conflict in Ukraine are reaching properly past the international locations and areas intently related to Russia and Ukraine by way of commerce and monetary linkages. Whereas the conflict is weighing on development, additionally it is including to already heightened inflationary pressures, significantly in rising market economies (EMEs), the place spending on power and meals constitutes a very giant share of personal consumption. As well as, the resurgence of the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic in Asia and the related tightening of containment measures, significantly in economically vital Chinese language provinces, are including strain to international provide chains following a short interval of easing earlier this yr. The implications of the Russian invasion and the pandemic measures in China are working in an setting of excessive inflationary pressures, which has prompted central banks throughout the globe to regulate their financial insurance policies, thereby contributing to tighter monetary situations.

Survey indicators sign that international exercise is moderating. The Buying Managers’ Index (PMI) surveys for Could recommend that financial exercise remained resilient throughout superior economies despite the continuing invasion, and that the companies sector continued to outpace the manufacturing sector. In distinction, extra muted financial exercise in EMEs displays developments in China and Russia (Chart 1). The worldwide exercise tracker, based mostly on a broader vary of indicators, confirms the tendencies proven in surveys. Total, estimated international actual GDP development – excluding the euro space – slowed considerably to 0.5% within the first quarter of 2022, consistent with the March 2022 ECB employees macroeconomic projections.

Disrupted financial exercise in Asia and the conflict in Ukraine are placing strain on international provide chains, following a short interval of easing earlier this yr. The PMI suppliers’ supply occasions had been enhancing all through March, particularly in america and United Kingdom (although the indicator was nonetheless pointing to lengthy supply occasions, remaining under the impartial threshold of fifty). This optimistic pattern was interrupted in April, when suppliers reported lengthening supply occasions. Within the case of america, nevertheless, a model-based evaluation means that this improvement was a results of stronger demand relatively than provide components. On the identical time, a marked lengthening of suppliers’ supply occasions in China – largely on account of lockdown-related provide components – has introduced the worldwide composite measure again to the degrees recorded in late 2021 when provide bottlenecks have been most acute. Extra lately suppliers’ supply occasions have shortened once more because the enhancing state of affairs in China meant strict measures have been eased in Could. Supply occasions in america and the UK have improved however are nonetheless removed from normalisation (Chart 2).

Provide chain and commodity market disruptions are contributing to inflation amid rising proof that worth pressures are intensifying and broadening. Annual headline CPI inflation throughout OECD international locations – excluding Turkey – rose to 7.2% in April, reaching its highest charge in over three many years. Annual inflation excluding power and meals elevated to 4.7%. As well as, the momentum in each headline and core inflation within the OECD space has picked up once more and moved near ranges recorded in mid-2021, when demand recovered as economies reopened (Chart 3). Survey knowledge for enter and output costs within the manufacturing sector affirm the elevated inflationary pressures for producers and shoppers, and costs within the companies sector are rising steadily. The final enhance in international commodity costs noticed this yr is predicted so as to add to already heightened inflation pressures within the close to time period, particularly throughout EMEs, the place power and meals account for a bigger share of client expenditure than in superior economies. Beneath the most recent conditioning assumptions, international client worth inflation is predicted to peak across the center of this yr and decline steadily over the remainder of the projection horizon.

The euro space economic system grew by 0.6% within the first quarter of 2022, thus standing 0.8% above its pre-pandemic degree. This stronger than anticipated final result was pushed by a double-digit quarterly GDP enhance in Eire. On common, the remainder of the euro space economic system grew by 0.3%. Modest optimistic development is predicted within the second quarter, because the beneficial impression from lifting pandemic-related restrictions on euro space exercise is counteracted by antagonistic components induced or amplified by the conflict in Ukraine, in addition to by new pandemic-related measures in China. Regardless of the restoration in consumption of contact-intensive companies, larger power and meals costs have dampened client sentiment and family spending. Persisting and even intensified provide chain disruptions, together with within the aftermath of the lockdowns in China and the conflict in Ukraine, are constraining manufacturing exercise and commerce. Elevated uncertainty, rising prices and tightening financing situations are additionally anticipated to weigh on each enterprise and housing funding within the coming quarters. Nonetheless, wanting past these weaker near-term development prospects, the situations are in place for the financial exercise within the euro space to regain momentum within the second half of the yr.

In line with Eurostat’s flash estimate inflation rose additional to eight.1% in Could, primarily due to surging power and meals costs, together with because of the impression of the conflict. Costs have additionally gone up extra strongly due to renewed provide bottlenecks and recovering home demand because the economic system reopens, particularly within the companies sector. Total, inflationary strain has broadened and intensified, and wage development has began to select up. Whereas most measures of longer-term inflation expectations derived from monetary markets and professional surveys stand at round 2%, preliminary indicators of above-target revisions in these measures warrant shut monitoring. Eurosystem employees have revised up their baseline for inflation within the June 2022 projections considerably in comparison with the March ECB employees projections. The brand new employees projections foresee annual inflation at 6.8% in 2022, 3.5% in 2023 and a couple of.1% in 2024.

In line with Eurostat’s flash estimate for Could, HICP inflation rose to a document excessive unprecedented within the historical past of the euro. The rise from 7.4% in April to eight.1% in Could displays larger inflation charges for all predominant elements, however most notably for power and meals. Client power costs, which stay the first contributor to headline inflation, edged up once more after a slight moderation in April. Excessive wholesale costs for fuel, oil and electrical energy, in addition to elevated refining and distribution margins for transport gas (significantly diesel oil) offset a downward impact of the compensatory measures adopted by euro space international locations. Meals inflation additionally rose considerably, pushed up by international meals commodity costs and home producer costs. This mirrored value components corresponding to these associated to power and fertilisers (Chart 8).

HICP excluding power and meals (HICPX) elevated to three.8%, reflecting an extra build-up in each non-energy industrial items (NEIG) and companies inflation (Chart 9). Right here, too, larger enter prices on account of the surge in power costs stay a distinguished driver. NEIG inflation can also be nonetheless affected by international provide disruptions, which have intensified on account of the conflict in Ukraine and the aftermath of pandemic-related developments in China. Companies inflation displays a number of the results arising from the reopening of the economic system as soon as pandemic-related restrictions have been lifted, as evidenced by the comparatively buoyant contributions from lodging and recreation companies in April 2022.

The euro space finances steadiness is projected to enhance steadily within the interval as much as 2024, though by considerably lower than foreseen within the March 2022 ECB employees macroeconomic projections and regardless of a greater than anticipated final result in 2021. The extra antagonistic outlook is expounded to a worsening of the financial cycle, elevated anticipated curiosity funds and extra discretionary authorities spending. Fiscal assist measures have been aimed specifically at countering the rising value of dwelling for shoppers, but in addition at financing defence capacities and supporting refugees from Russia’s conflict in Ukraine. Nonetheless, based on the June 2022 Eurosystem employees macroeconomic projections, the euro space authorities finances deficit is predicted to proceed falling – from 5.1% of GDP in 2021 to three.8% in 2022 and additional to 2.4% by the tip of the forecast horizon. After the sturdy loosening through the coronavirus (COVID-19) disaster in 2020, the fiscal stance tightened final yr and is projected to proceed to tighten steadily in 2022 and 2023. The projected slight tightening in 2022 is especially because of the reversal of a big a part of the COVID-19 pandemic emergency assist, which might be solely partially compensated by further stimulus measures in response to the power worth shock and different spending associated to the Russia-Ukraine conflict. The fiscal tightening is projected to be considerably stronger in 2023, when most of the latest assist measures compensating for the impression of excessive power costs are projected to run out. In 2024 a extra impartial stance is predicted, though important fiscal assist to the economic system is projected to stay in place in comparison with the pre-pandemic interval. In a context of heightened uncertainty and draw back dangers to the financial outlook within the mild of the conflict in Ukraine, in addition to power worth will increase and continued provide chain disturbances, the European Fee advisable on 23 Could 2022 the extension of the final escape clause of the Stability and Progress Pact (SGP) to the tip of 2023. This is able to permit fiscal insurance policies to regulate to altering circumstances if essential. On the identical time, with fiscal imbalances nonetheless exceeding their pre-pandemic ranges and inflation exceptionally excessive, fiscal coverage must be more and more selective and focused so as to not add to medium-term inflationary pressures, whereas guaranteeing fiscal sustainability over the medium time period.

Ready by Jakob Feveile Adolfsen, Friderike Kuik, Eliza Magdalena Lis and Tobias Schuler

The conflict in Ukraine has generated a pointy enhance in power costs and important volatility in power markets. Amid fears of disruptions to power provides and more and more strict sanctions on the Russian power sector, costs have fluctuated, specifically as markets have tried to evaluate the potential implications for international power provides. Given their heavy reliance on Russian provides earlier than the invasion, euro space power markets have been particularly affected. This field gives an summary of the impression that the conflict in Ukraine has had on euro space power markets to date. It outlines Russia’s position within the euro space’s power provide and appears at measures which have influenced costs. On this context, it additionally discusses the implications for euro space power commodity and client costs.

Ready by Alina Bobasu and Roberto A. De Santis

Ready by Vasco Botelho

Ready by Friderike Kuik, Richard Morris and Yiqiao Solar

Ready by Malin Andersson, Niccolò Battistini, Roberto De Santis and Aidan Meyler

Ready by Katalin Bodnár and Tobias Schuler

Ready by Joonas Koukkunen and Anne van der Graaf

This field describes the ECB’s financial coverage operations and liquidity developments through the first and second reserve upkeep intervals of 2022. Collectively, these two upkeep intervals ran from 9 February 2022 to 19 April 2022 (the “overview interval”).

Ready by Friderike Kuik, Jakob Feveile Adolfsen, Eliza Magdalena Lis, Aidan Meyler

Ready by Fédéric Holm-Hadulla, Alberto Musso, Giulio Nicoletti and Mika Tujula

Ready by Javier Huerga, Antonio Matas, Anne-Lise Nguyen, Pascal Nicoloso and Vladimir Tsonchev