Save for a Home or Retirement? Select the Latter


The final decade of my life has seen one annual fixed: contributing to a retirement plan.

Given the glories of compound curiosity over time, I’ve been a borderline zealot in the best way wherein I proselytize for my fellow millennials and our Gen Z compatriots to contribute to their retirement funds. I’ve at all times mentioned you need to not less than contribute sufficient to get your worker match whereas specializing in different monetary targets (or shackles) like constructing an emergency fund or repaying scholar loans.

Then I used to be confronted with balancing my very own desires of New York Metropolis homeownership in opposition to my want to save lots of for retirement. Ought to I press pause on investing for retirement to funnel a lump sum of money towards a down cost?

Seems I used to be proper all alongside.

Final month, I thought of rerouting the quantity I’d put aside for my 2022 retirement contribution to a financial savings fund for a down cost. Since I’m self-employed, I don’t have an employer who contributes to my retirement account, however I can use a SEP IRA, which permits for a most contribution that’s the lesser of 25% of an worker’s whole compensation or $61,000 in 2022. (It’s been elevated to $66,000 in 2023.)

Then I despatched my accountant the data for my estimated taxes for the fourth quarter. But one more reason self-employment isn’t at all times glamorous — we’ve got to save lots of up for and pay estimated taxes quarterly, in contrast to our W2 counterparts who merely have their employers withhold taxes for them.

Just a few days later my accountant known as with the outcomes. If I didn’t contribute to my SEP IRA in any respect, I’d owe nearly $8,000 extra in taxes than if I maxed out my SEP IRA contribution for the yr. (The quantity I’d put aside wouldn’t totally max out my annual contribution restrict, however nonetheless would have resulted in me owing $6,000 extra in taxes). That’s a down cost for some folks!

Maybe, to some, $6,000 appears a small quantity to quibble over in case you’re nonetheless placing a lump sum in direction of a down cost for a house in an costly metropolis. However to me, it appears like a state of affairs the place I’d be slicing off my nostril to spite my face. The sum that will have remained after paying my huge tax invoice was too modest an quantity to be an advantageous technique in contrast with lowering my tax legal responsibility and establishing my future self for a stronger retirement.

Nonetheless, I totally settle for that there are lots of folks for whom it does make sense to take a knee, or higher acknowledged, scale back retirement contributions for a yr or two to concentrate on shoring up money reserves for a down cost on a house. In fact, I’d nonetheless plead that they not less than benefit from any accessible employer match. However, the query of whether or not or to not prioritize home-ownership financial savings over retirement contributions is a very glorious instance of why “it relies upon” is the reply to each private finance query.

As my colleague and editor, Alexis Leondis, has illustrated, proudly owning a house, particularly outright, pays vital dividends in retirement. It allows these on a hard and fast revenue to higher management the price of housing whereas those that are renting are topic to the whims of a landlord’s charges and the state of the rental market.

Two-bedroom flats in Manhattan carry a median rental value of $4,650 after a dramatic improve of $720 within the final yr, based on Zillow’s market analysis. Issues could also be stabilizing, however New York is a metropolis whose renters will at all times be on the mercy of a risky and costly housing market, excepting the lucky minority who’ve rent-controlled or stabilized models.

Most Individuals don’t reside in main metropolitan areas. Those that reside in areas with houses at extra cheap costs could possibly take a yr or two off from contributing to a retirement fund as a way to funnel the 1000’s of {dollars} wanted for a down cost into financial savings. Maybe they reside in one of many 9 states with out revenue tax, so pausing contributions to a tax-advantaged account has even much less influence than for his or her counterparts who pay state revenue tax.

For my state of affairs, I noticed there was one other retirement account I may faucet with out such a tax hit: my Roth IRA. A byproduct of a Roth 401(okay) from a former employer, my Roth IRA comprises just a few years of post-tax contributions. It’s greater than 5 years previous, which suggests I can withdraw my contributions with out triggering taxes or a penalty. As a first-time dwelling purchaser, I may take a further $10,000 out as a professional withdrawal, which doesn’t set off revenue tax or the ten% tax penalty for being underneath 59 and 1/2. Provided that my SEP IRA is the one upon which my retirement calculations are constructed, I don’t see a difficulty with gutting my Roth IRA for a a lot shorter-term monetary purpose than retirement.

The choice to raiding any of my retirement accounts is the tried-and-true technique of aggressively saving by lowering discretionary spending. Not being one for the monastic life, the opposite choice is to scale back discretionary spending modestly whereas specializing in methods to extend revenue and in the end, financial savings. That’s a spot the place self-employed folks might have an edge: We might not have employer matches, however we could possibly improve our incomes quicker than our historically employed counterparts.

Extra From This Author at Bloomberg Opinion:

• Are You Able to Take Care of Your Boomer Mother and father?: Erin Lowry

• Don’t Flip Your Passion Right into a Aspect Hustle: Erin Lowry

• New Roommate? Why You Ought to Make Your Grownup Child Pay Lease: Erin Lowry

This column doesn’t essentially mirror the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its homeowners.

Erin Lowry is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist masking private finance. She is the creator of the three-part “Broke Millennial” sequence.

Extra tales like this can be found on

Related Posts

Next Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Follow Us